18th November 2024
 · 
6 min read
Tagged: design · education

Is Design Too Cool For School?

Is a degree still a necessary investment for a career in Industrial Design?

Photo by Matt Ragland

I was in Melbourne last week attending a "masterclass" on behalf of a client. To save on a crazy-early start to fly down and back on the same day, I flew down the night before. I had lined up to meet with some younger Industrial Designers for dinner, and as luck would have it, we rendezvoused at the RMIT grad design show to check out the new talent prior to heading out for the evening.

Graduating university for me was a lifetime ago. I don't even remember most of it, though I certainly remember it being up there with one of the best times of my life. I still have many of the artifacts I produced buried under the house somewhere. Perhaps initially intended to be kept for reference, they remain there mostly because they too have been forgotten. In all likelihood, my kids will have to throw them out when I die.

It was quite nostalgic for me to wander through all the final-year projects. You can smell the optimism and naivety in the air. And the complete absence of commercial pressures; permitting these students to dream up whatever problem fits the solution they want to build. That said, they set a high bar. The level of polish far higher than when I graduated.

I graduated from Newcastle University, and back then I think it was considered quite a solid course by all the usual measures. Eventually though it got parred down, where the lion's share of the course was moved to a product design diploma at TAFE with the last year completed at the Uni to qualify for the degree. By all reports it actually made the course better. But now there is no course at all.

Here's the kicker. Not once in my 22 year career have I been asked to show evidence of my Industrial Design degree. Every job I got, even the first one, was based on the skill set I've presented in my portfolio, or the skills I demonstrated on the job.

I believe in the Information Age, you could establish yourself as an Industrial Designer, without having ever gone to university. And sitting at the table during dinner this week, listening to these young designers talk about their experiences, only strengthened my argument.

How Exactly Would You Do That?

When I graduated, there was no YouTube, no online courses, no social media (as we know it), even an email address wasn't really a thing that you needed. Now we do, and with it comes two things; access to all the world's knowledge and experience; and, access to all the world's people.

If you have the drive, it is quite possible to be a self-taught career Industrial Designer.

Knowledge

Starting with the most obvious, literally anything you would want to learn about Industrial Design is on YouTube. From learning how to sketch and CAD model, to design theory on form and colour psychology. It's all there with enough digging.

There are of course plenty of online courses beyond what's available on YouTube. Most Youtubers have their own courses. Design Theory's John Mauriello is one with his Form Fundamentals. Le Manoosh also hosts a number of courses worth looking at, among others. When I first started my design consulting, The Futur was invaluable for me to help get my feet under me. While their content is more geared toward commercialising, rather than developing creative skills, they've been a great resource for me. If you want to pony up the money, they also have great workshops and coaching.

And that's just the tip of iceberg. The Internet Archive is full of cool design stuff, as is your local library. In fact, for a fee you may even be able to access your local university library.

Access

However, having some guidance to bring all the skills and knowledge together is equally important. That's where it's essential to get connected into the design industry. Start talking to people who work in it, find a community, and find yourself a mentor.

Someone with experience willing to give up some of their time to provide you the top-level guidance and feedback can accelerate your design skills much faster than if you'd just sat at home practicing your sketching. They don't have to run a design studio. Even a designer with half a dozen years under their belt will be able to give you valuable input that will enable you to grow.

I feel old for saying it, but my design degree cost me the equivalent of $75k in today's money. $75k would go a very long way to paying one or more mentors for their time. That's even if they let you pay them.

The Special Sauce

I make it sound easy, but I can assure you it would be far from it.

The special sauce to be able to pull this off is the unwavering drive to see it through. To commit to spending vast amounts of time learning the skills and gaining knowledge, often in the dark about what it is that you should be doing.

Knowing that if you want a design career, nobody is going to give it to you. You have to take it.

Would not having a degree limit your job opportunities? Probably, but not in a bad way. I personally wouldn't care if a job applicant was self-taught if their portfolio showed they had strength in the skills I was looking for. I would also suspect many other design managers wouldn't care either. It might even be an asset. And the managers that do care, where your certificate matters more than the examples of your work, you might not want to be employed by anyway.

The Other Thing

Of course there's more to going to university than just gaining the knowledge and skills for a career in Industrial Design. From listening to my fellow designers around the table the other night, you may get a whole lot more than you bargain for. My takeaway was that these people almost got their degrees despite their lecturers, not because of them. Stories of unfair marking, unreasonable feedback, poor subject choices, misogynism, and under-resourcing seemed to be a theme. While a self-taught designer might miss out on some friendly competition and comradery, they certainly wouldn't miss the rest.

And a Grain of Salt

It should be worth noting that I got a degree like a good little Industrial Designer. My path to Industrial Design was pathed with ignorance. I'm not a self-taught designer, though I've done my fair share of self-teaching the last few years. Nor do I know anyone who is self-taught. But that's not to say that things couldn't, and shouldn't, change.

The last question may be then, if all the world's designers stopped getting degrees, would it cheapen the Industrial Design profession? Could it be still called a profession? My retort might be; would that be any worse than where we are now?

ⓒ Lincoln Black 2024

Virmachi-Logo-White-Transparent

Virtimachi Pty Ltd

ABN 31 651 760 762

PO Box 7156 Kariong

NSW 2250 Australia