You'll see it too, when you start glazing over.
Despite being somewhat of an AI sceptic, I do subscribe to the RSS feed for LessWrong. LessWrong, for those that don't know, is an online forum that is (in their words) dedicated to improving human reasoning and decision-making. While I've found a few good articles via LessWrong, it is (or has become) extremely AI-centric. No so much AI-generated, though there's a bit of that, more that LessWrong consists of a great number of people talking about AI. Most notably, AI alignment, which is just an AI apologists way of saying "not hallucinate". I glaze over at most of the headlines that involve AI discussion, though it's probably not a bad thing to see what's going on in the world of LLMs.
In fact, and this is somewhat of a side note, glazing over is a very useful thing to do on occasion. Glazing over allows you to stop looking at the details of what you're studying, and get an idea of the general shape of it. My wife has been working on a few jigsaw puzzles recently and I got sucked into working on one of them one evening. I found that deliberately defocusing my vision allowed me to see the colours of the pieces, both in place and yet to be placed, and I could better sort by colour match without the distraction of detail. likewise, as designers we often get buried in the details of our designs, and stop seeing the forest for the trees. 'Glazing over' seems like a great way to force your attention back to the overall shape of things.
Back to LessWrong, in my glazed state (it's not lost on me that Glaze is also a tool to poison digital art against AI scraping) something occurred to me that most of the discussion about AI, on LessWrong at least, is speculation. Sure, there is some discussion about what AI does and doesn't do now, but most of it is about what AI might do at some indeterminate time in the future.
If we glaze even harder, and see the general shape of our society, it's speculation all the way down.
Certainly, the whole AI industry is built on speculation. Sam Altman is the master of telling us what AI is gunna do, even if it never does. Elon Musk is another perfect example of telling us what Tesla is gunna do, even if it doesn't. In both of these cases, and many like it, the entire purpose of talking about what any company is gunna do is to pump the stock. That's because the stock market is built entirely on speculation. Buying stock because the stock, not the company, might increase in value.
We can look at all recent bubbles through the same unfocused lens. The metaverse, and of course crypto. Cryptocurrency is quite literally an industry (what's left of it) speculating on speculation. What continues to surprise me is that people still pour money into #whatevercoin and expect anything other than losing it all. Such is the power of speculation. Even when you chose to fill up your car is often based on speculation. Will fuel prices go up or down? Will filling up now save me a few dollars over filling up tomorrow? The infinite scroll of social media is engineered for speculation too. Will you see the greatest post ever to grace human history, if you scroll up just one more time? Just once more. One more.
Closer to [occupational] home, the same is true for startups. We invest our time and money into our startups because we believe one day they will have societal and financial value. Certainly, investors give startups money because they're speculating on some future worth of that company. Even public funding bodies are speculating on some future value of grant recipients. Either the value of the company, the value of its technology to society, or the value of its production to the economy. Or more likely, some combination of all three.
In July's linkdump I linked an article by Joan Westenberg that proposed the idea of a Maximum Viable Promise, over a Minimum Viable Product. Without regurgitating the whole article, the premise is that one must invest as much or more into building the Maximum Viable Promise - your vision, as one should in the MVP. The Maximum Viable Promise is what people invest in. Or rather, the Maximum Viable Promise is what people speculate on.
Industrial Designers are often good story tellers when it comes to what our designs do, and why they are the way they are. But this is all too often a too detail-oriented view. We need to spend more time glazing over to see the general shape of things. We need to expand our storytelling to include why consumers should even care in the first place.
Consumers also buy products on speculation. Unless they already have the product, they don't really know how it's going to impact their lives. They speculate that the purchase of good X or Y will return value in some form based on the story that product tells. That value may not be financial return, though it could be, it can also include money saved, or time saved, a better user experience, or simply to show off. This story certainly includes the design (colour, form, etc.), but also the tech specs, branding, buying channels, who's selling it to you, availability (including artificial scarcity), and so on.
Your clients are even speculating on your ability to turn their vision into reality through the power of Industrial Design. And they've made that choice based on the story you tell, deliberately or otherwise. This is why large agencies with storied histories can command higher rates; it's the fee they demand for what appears to be a less risky investment and by extension, and more guaranteed return. Though nothing in life is ever guaranteed, including life itself.
Learning how to sell is outside the scope of both this article and my expertise. For many designers, including me, story telling on that kind of level is way outside our wheelhouses and tips into the realms of sales and marketing. Still, understanding that much of what we do causes, and is caused by, speculation is a useful exercise. It's another form of empathy, one that should be part of every good design process, but asks a specific yet broad question: Consumers, investors, clients are speculating, what are we giving them to speculate on?
By glazing over, we can provide ourselves with an unfocused lens through which to see how the work we do fits into the bigger puzzle.
