15th July 2024
 · 
5 min read
Tagged: business · design · sustainability · technology

Technofeudalism and Design

Are walled gardens destroying meaningful product design?

You might have heard of the Spotify Car Thing?

Released in 2021, Car Thing is little doohickey with a screen and a knob for controlling your phone's playback remotely. It only works with Spotify Premium. As an owner of an old car that still rocks a cassette tape player (which my kids love), I thought the idea was a nifty one for people like me. All the mod-cons of a dash-mounted UI, without actually needing to replace the head unit.

Why Spotify brought it to market I'm unsure, but if I was to guess it was to both sidestep whatever infotainment platform cars had integrated, while possibly trying to incentivise users to move to Spotify Premium. Then by extension encouraging greater consumption of Spotify content (thus more revenue).

I might have bought one if they were available in Aus.

Yeah, well Spotify just clicked it's fingers and all Car Things are about to become bricked.

Technofeudalism

If you're unfamiliar with the term technofeudalism, it's a term coined by economist Yanis Varoufakis in his book of the same name.

Cory Doctorow does a good breakdown on what it is, but in short it's the digital platforms on which capitalists operate. The capitalist provides goods and services for profit. The feudalist charges rent for the land on which they do it. Think Amazon, Apple's App Store, Spotify. Each of these megacorps "own" the platform (land) and charge rent to the capitalists who sell things on it.

The Amazon seller must pay Amazon up to 50% of every dollar earned. The app developer has to pay Apple 30% of revenue for the privilege of operating on and being limited to the App Store. The artist receives just fractions of one cent per stream from Spotify in return to access to their subscriber base.

As with all feudal systems, whoever owns the land can do whatever they want with it, whenever they want. And in the case of technofeudalism, those changes can literally happen overnight.

Changes made within these walled gardens almost always are made to increase shareholder value. And when the value transfers to shareholders, it has to come from somewhere. Even it comes via the capitalists, it's ultimately transferred away from consumers.

I've said it once before, but it bears repeating. Anything you buy that is connected to the Internet, you should assume will be taken away from you. Either brazenly like the Car Thing, through double-speak like Google Search, or over a long period in small amounts like the iPhone.

While the Car Thing certainly has some cost to it, given Spotify generated €13.24 billion in revenue in 2023, I'm sure Spotify discontinuing it had less to do with the cost of goods, and more to do with making number go up.

Poor Thing

In the case of the Car Thing, and all internet-connected physical products, the collateral damage is a little more complex. It is not only the customer that is directly impacted by having the device they paid for remotely and irreversibly deactivated. So too are retailers, manufacturers, supply chains, and the designers and engineers that put in the elbow grease to bring it to fruition.

Oh, and THE ENVIRONMENT.

In many ways the Car Thing was well designed. It ran a commodity processor that was just good enough to run what it had to. It did what it had to do, and nothing more. I like that. Unfortunately that also means it's basically useless to jailbreak and use it for something else in order to, you know, save it from landfill.

Side quest: Amazon is also bricking its Astro robot after only 10 months. At least Amazon is offering to recycle them - take that for what it's worth.

What it Means for Design

When consumers keep getting Juicero'd time and time again. When the products they've paid good money for are rendered obsolete for the sole purpose of making rich people richer. When it is real people that have to toss those very real products in the waste*.

* I'm not even going to start on the war on durability and repairability that further bolster the revenues of these companies.

What will happen to society's perception of these products, and by extension the passionate humans that design and develop them?

I've never worked on a product that was made obsolete so quickly and so deliberately. I would imagine seeing that happen to your own hard work would be soul-crushing. Through no fault of their own either, a product that fails consumers can look bad on the designers and engineers that brought it to life. Even if it worked flawlessly. Imagine telling a potential employer or client; "Oh yeah, I worked on the Juicero".

At this point I would also like to point out that despite it being widely accepted that Teenage Engineering developed the design for the Rabbit R1, they've never claimed authorship of the design. Read into that what you will.

On one hand, Industrial Designers are always on the lookout for work. The opportunity to work on some new hype-product for one of these megacorps would be very attractive (and lucrative). On the other hand, if they were told from the outset that whatever they designed will be thrown in the bin en masse three years later, what would change?

Physical product design is already extraordinarily difficult. Designing a tech product that can also somehow be responsibly discarded shortly after would be exponentially so.

Some designers simply might not care. Some might try and integrate some system-level agnostics (like Linux or AOSP) that would permit consumers to meaningfully repurpose their devices. Others still might design the devices to be easily dismantled, or built of more homogenous materials in the faint hope some of it gets recycled.

Sadly, I think the reality is much bleaker.

When I constantly find single-use vapes along the side of the road, and perfectly good products sitting in bulk waste collection, I think most consumers simply don't care. And the small percentage that does care can feel utterly demoralised when Google's greenhouse gas emissions can increase almost 50% in five years pumping AI to make their number go up.

The net result is that without any systemic change, without treating these disposable products like the toxic corporate runoff they are, it'll continue to be waste. Waste all the way down.

So We Just Lay Down and Die?

Despite, or perhaps because of, all that I just want to remind all designers and engineers that, however powerless you feel, your ability to influence the lifecycle of these products is second only to the CEOs of these companies that kill them.

Let that sink in.

ⓒ Lincoln Black 2024

Virmachi-Logo-White-Transparent

Virtimachi Pty Ltd

ABN 31 651 760 762

PO Box 7156 Kariong

NSW 2250 Australia